Users are redirected to the dashboard regardless of sign-up success on branch step/1

[keplib]

Hi,

I'm quite new to Next.js, so this might just be a question rather than an issue. However, I have some doubts about the implementation of the user registration in actions/auth.ts:

From what I understand, it seems like users are redirected to the dashboard regardless of whether the sign-up was successful. I think this behavior might not be ideal, as it could result in users being redirected even if there was an error during registration.

My proposed solution would be:

• Return {success: true} in the try block and {success: false} in the catch block to clearly indicate the outcome of the action.

• On the client side (in SignupForm.tsx), use useEffect and useRouter to redirect users to the dashboard only when the action response indicates success.

I realize that this might be addressed later in the course, but I wanted to share my thoughts in case this is an oversight. If this is indeed acknowledged as an issue, what would the next steps be for fixing it?

Thanks!