diff --git a/RedditSharp/Reddit.cs b/RedditSharp/Reddit.cs
index 00902ea..4c88f0d 100644
--- a/RedditSharp/Reddit.cs
+++ b/RedditSharp/Reddit.cs
@@ -348,7 +348,7 @@ public void ComposePrivateMessage(string subject, string body, string to, string
                 CaptchaResponse captchaResponse = solver.HandleCaptcha(new Captcha(captchaId));
 
                 if (!captchaResponse.Cancel) // Keep trying until we are told to cancel
-                    ComposePrivateMessage(subject, body, to, captchaId, captchaResponse.Answer);
+                    ComposePrivateMessage(subject, body, to, fromSubReddit, captchaId, captchaResponse.Answer);
             }
         }