You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Ecosystem alignment: The rest of dotnet uses portable PDBs. The .NET symbol pipeline already handles converting portable PDBs to Windows PDBs for native debugging scenarios — so portable PDBs don't prevent Windows-native debugging.
Recommendation
Consider switching WPF to <DebugType>portable</DebugType> (or removing the override to use the SDK default, which is portable). The .NET symbol pipeline can produce Windows PDBs from portable PDBs for any native debugging needs.
cc @tommcdon@hoyosjs — would appreciate your thoughts on whether there's a specific reason WPF needs Windows-native PDBs, or if this is a legacy setting that could be updated.
Summary
WPF explicitly sets
DebugTypetofull(Debug) /pdbonly(Release) for all managed projects viaeng/WpfArcadeSdk/Sdk/Sdk.props:This means all 70 WPF C# compilations produce Windows-native PDBs instead of portable PDBs.
Why this matters
Source indexing: The source indexer uses
ReadGeneratedFilesFromPdb(from complog) to extract source-generator output and include it in the source index at https://source.dot.net. This API only works with portable PDBs. As a result, all source-generated code in WPF (XAML-generatedInitializeComponent(), etc.) is missing from the source index. See BinLogToSln warning for projects using non-portable PDB format source-indexer#256.Ecosystem alignment: The rest of dotnet uses portable PDBs. The .NET symbol pipeline already handles converting portable PDBs to Windows PDBs for native debugging scenarios — so portable PDBs don't prevent Windows-native debugging.
Recommendation
Consider switching WPF to
<DebugType>portable</DebugType>(or removing the override to use the SDK default, which isportable). The .NET symbol pipeline can produce Windows PDBs from portable PDBs for any native debugging needs.cc @tommcdon @hoyosjs — would appreciate your thoughts on whether there's a specific reason WPF needs Windows-native PDBs, or if this is a legacy setting that could be updated.