Conversation
This: - adds hooks feature for copilot Notes: Copilot has an unique hooks format, where it allows for defining the command through `bash` or `powershell` fields. Depending on the platform you're on, either `powershell` or `bash` are required. There are different ways in which this mismatch could be resolved. This chooses to read the user's platform and generate bash or powershell accordingly. If the user wants to maintain both, then they'll need to use copilot-specific overrides.
|
@dyoshikawa This one is a little bit more complicated due to copilot's unusual format. I was considering different approaches, but in the end landed on the one implemented, as described in the commit message. One thing worth noting is that I decided to pass through unknown fields when generating, instead of skipping them, to allow users to define Copilot's It seems that currently handling of translation between rulesync's format and agent's format is inconsistent: depending on the feature or agent, we're either passing these fields through or ignoring them when exporting. When importing we're mostly ignoring unknown fields, except for rules, where we put them under agent specific configuration - this approach is not possible to achieve with other features because of how overrides work there. I think it'd be worthwhile to consolidate these approaches, but that'd probably require rethinking how we do agent-specific overrides for all agents. I do have some ideas, so I might write up an issue if you want, but at the same time, changing this now would be a big breaking change. Let me know if you find anything in this PR or even would like to approach Copilot's format differently. Thanks! |
|
Thank you! |
|
/oc review |
PR #1191 Review Summary: feat: implement hooks for copilotCode Review Results ✅Summary: Well-implemented PR adding hooks feature for GitHub Copilot with platform-specific Minor Issues:
Positive Aspects:
Verdict: ✅ Approve Security Review Results ✅No vulnerabilities detected. The implementation is secure:
Security Best Practices Followed:
Overall Assessment✅ PR #1191 is ready for merge. Both code quality and security reviews pass with only minor, non-blocking recommendations for future improvement. |
This:
Notes:
Copilot has an unique hooks format, where it allows for defining the command through
bashorpowershellfields. Depending on the platform you're on, eitherpowershellorbashare required. There are different ways in which this mismatch could be resolved. This chooses to read the user's platform and generate bash or powershell accordingly. If the user wants to maintain both, then they'll need to use copilot-specific overrides.Closes #1006