Conversation
rtburns-jpl
left a comment
rtburns-jpl
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@piyushrpt do you think this is a reasonable assumption to make? Can you imagine a situation where someone would want the extraFilename to be remote as well?
| self.extraFilename = self.filename + '.' + self._extra_reader | ||
| #if the filename is a URL, the extraFilename should indicate the file from the local machine | ||
| #instead of from the remote server. | ||
| if self.filename.startswith('http'): |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
| if self.filename.startswith('http'): | |
| if self.filename.startswith('http://') or self.filename.startswith('https://'): |
It may be possible someone's filename starts with http, but I wouldn't expect a local filename to contain //
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Why not create a .vrt and .xml and have source in vrt to point to remote? That way you have a record of what resource was actually used? That way you are not restricted to something thats just http / https. You can throw in anything vsis3 / vsiaz/ vsicurl etc. This approach still seems to need a .vrt. Just using basename of .vrt should be enough when it points to other things?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
@piyushrpt I did create a .vrt that points to a remote geotiff. In my use case, the XML is not needed. Here's an example of what would happen if running this snippet using the original code version:
import isce
from isceobj.Image.Image import Image
obj = Image()
obj.setFilename("https://download.osgeo.org/geotiff/samples/GeogToWGS84GeoKey/GeogToWGS84GeoKey5.tif")
obj.setWidth(101)
obj.setDataType('SHORT')
obj.setCaster('read', 'FLOAT')
obj.createImage()
# ... (continue to some Ampcor code)
GDAL open (R): https://download.osgeo.org/geotiff/samples/GeogToWGS84GeoKey/GeogToWGS84GeoKey5.tif.vrt
ERROR 1: HTTP error code : 404
Error. Cannot open the file https://download.osgeo.org/geotiff/samples/GeogToWGS84GeoKey/GeogToWGS84GeoKey5.tif.vrt in read mode.
Error in file /home/whyj/Software/isce2-2.4.2-build/isce/components/iscesys/ImageApi/InterleavedAccessor/src/GDALAccessor.cpp at line 77 Exiting
You can see that the ISCE's default behavior is to read a VRT that is at the same location as the original file, and it does not matter whether you have created a VRT on your local machine or not. If we replace the geotiff file name with the local vrt, ISCE will try to gdal open .vrt.vrt, which does not exist.
Explicitly identify URL file names Co-authored-by: Ryan Burns <rtburns@jpl.nasa.gov>
3 participants
As discussed in #243, I edited the rule for finding the VRT -- if the file name is actually a URL, the Data Accessor will read the corresponding VRT file (that points to the remote, original file) on the local machine. It should be compatible with almost all the ICSE use cases. Let me know if you have any questions about this change.
Thanks!